November 19, 2026
•
9min read
•
Roundups

8 Questions to Ask Before Hiring a Marketing Agency

A comprehensive list of practical questions to help you select a marketing agency that best fits your business needs.

Table of contents

Hiring a marketing agency can help your business reach new customers, improve campaign performance, and access expertise you may not have in-house. And it’s a fairly common practice.  

According to Marketing Week's 2025 Career & Salary Survey, 63.1% of more than 3,500 respondents had outsourced work to an agency or third party in the preceding 12 months, up from 46.2% the previous year.

The websites are polished, the claims are big, and the work looks good, too. Keep in mind, they’re marketers. What you truly need is a partner that best fits your needs and where you want your business to be. 

You’ll learn most about an agency and the team behind it when you sit down to talk with them. And you need to ask them questions that distinguish the best fit from the rest. With that in mind, this guide covers eight important questions to ask any agency candidate, plus the kind of answer you want and the red flags to watch out for. 

1. Does the Agency Have Experience in Your Industry?

Industry experience is one of the first things to consider when evaluating a marketing agency. An agency familiar with your sector may already understand your customers, competitors, sales cycles, and the challenges businesses like yours face.

This is all the more relevant for niche industries with their own marketing challenges. For instance, B2B marketing is very different from selling directly to consumers. You have long sales cycles and multiple buyers involved. Not exactly like convincing an individual to press a ‘buy now’ button. 

Industry expertise can also be particularly important in regulated sectors such as healthcare and financial services, where marketing communications must meet specific legal and advertising requirements.

That said, don't automatically rule out agencies that haven't worked in your exact industry. Agencies with experience in similar markets may bring transferable expertise, fresh perspectives, and creative ideas that competitors haven't explored.

What a strong answer looks like

A capable agency should explain how its industry experience connects to your business needs in addition to naming any clients. They should also be able to explain any lack of experience in that industry and how they can make up for it.

Ask the agency to provide:

  • Relevant case studies: Examples of campaigns delivered for businesses in your industry or similar markets.
  • Industry-specific insights: Knowledge of your target audience, competitors, buying behaviors, and marketing challenges.
  • Applicable expertise: Experience with comparable products, sales cycles, budgets, or customer segments.
  • Client references: Opportunities to speak with previous clients about their experience working with the agency.

Red flag to watch out for

Be cautious if an agency claims expertise across every industry but doesn’t provide relevant examples. A portfolio filled with recognizable brands doesn't necessarily mean experience.

2. What Marketing Services Do You Specialize In?

Most agencies offer more than one service. You want to work with one that specializes in the type of marketing you need. 

Some agencies specialize in individual disciplines, such as search engine optimization (SEO), pay-per-click (PPC) advertising, or social media marketing. 

It’s highly recommended to go with specialists over generalists because they’re more experienced and focused. A review website like Growth Partner Index is usually a good place to find agencies with specific specialties.

A specialized agency may be ideal when you need advanced expertise in one area, while a full-service agency can be useful when you want several marketing activities managed under a coordinated strategy.

Before approaching agencies, identify the capabilities your internal team already possesses and where additional expertise is required.

What a strong answer looks like

A strong agency should be transparent about its core capabilities and explain which services best match your objectives. It should also clarify whether its internal specialists will complete the work or outsource it to external partners.

Look for clear answers to these questions:

  • Which marketing services generate the strongest results for your clients?
  • Do you have dedicated specialists for each service?
  • How do you coordinate campaigns across multiple marketing channels?
  • Which services do you outsource, if any?
  • Can you recommend services based on our goals rather than offering a fixed package?

Red flag to watch out for

Watch out for agencies that promise exceptional results across every marketing discipline without demonstrating specialist expertise.

Another warning sign is recommending multiple services before discussing your goals, resources, or existing marketing performance. 

3. Can You Show Me Results You've Achieved for Similar Clients?

An agency's past performance can provide valuable insight into its capabilities. However, attractive campaign visuals, client testimonials, and impressive-looking statistics don't always tell the complete story.

When reviewing an agency's portfolio, look for measurable business outcomes. That means don’t fall for numbers like impressions or clicks from a Meta campaign. Look for metrics like cost per acquisition (CPA) or return on ad spend (ROAS). Those tell whether marketing moved the needle for a business. 

But keep your expectations realistic. Remember that results achieved for another business won't necessarily be replicated for yours. Campaign performance depends on factors like competition, budgets, product positioning, market conditions, and execution.

What a strong answer looks like

A credible agency should provide case studies explaining the client's original challenge, the strategy implemented, and the results achieved.

Ideally, these examples should cover:

  • Initial objectives: What the client wanted to accomplish and which challenges needed to be addressed.
  • Strategy and execution: The marketing channels, tactics, and resources the agency used.
  • Performance metrics: Relevant outcomes such as qualified leads, conversion rates, customer acquisition costs, revenue, or ROAS.
  • Campaign duration: How long it took to achieve the reported results.
  • Supporting evidence: Client testimonials, reporting screenshots, or references that help verify the claims.

Ask the agency to explain why certain campaigns succeeded and what it learned from campaigns that performed below expectations.

Red flag to watch out for

Be wary of agencies that rely heavily on vague claims such as "we deliver outstanding ROI" without providing supporting evidence.

Another warning sign is presenting impressive percentages without context. A 200% increase in leads sounds remarkable, but an increase from two monthly leads to six may not justify a substantial investment.

4. How Do You Develop and Execute a Marketing Strategy?

Successful marketing usually starts with a clear strategy. Unless you just need an execution partner, you need a marketing agency that does the legwork before shooting ads, designing creatives, and targeting an audience. 

Before recommending tactics, a marketing agency should understand what your business wants to accomplish, whom it needs to reach, and which marketing activities are most likely to deliver results.

This process typically involves reviewing existing performance, analyzing competitors, researching target audiences, and identifying opportunities across relevant channels.

It's also worth asking how the agency translates its strategy into actual campaigns. A compelling presentation means little unless the agency has a practical execution plan with responsibilities, deliverables, and timelines.

What a strong answer looks like

A capable agency should have a structured approach to strategy development while remaining flexible enough to address your unique requirements.

Its process should generally include:

  • Discovery and research: Understanding your business objectives, customers, competitors, and current marketing activities.
  • Performance assessment: Reviewing existing campaigns, analytics, and marketing resources to establish a baseline.
  • Strategy development: Choosing appropriate channels, messaging, budgets, and priorities.
  • Implementation planning: Defining deliverables, responsibilities, timelines, and approval processes.
  • Continuous optimization: Testing campaigns, reviewing performance, and adjusting the strategy based on results.

Ask what the agency expects to accomplish during the first 30, 60, and 90 days of the partnership.

Red flag to watch out for

An agency that proposes a detailed marketing strategy without asking meaningful questions about your business may be relying on a generic approach.

5. How Do You Use AI in Your Marketing Processes?

Artificial intelligence is changing how marketing agencies research audiences, develop creative assets, manage campaigns, and analyze performance. As a result, understanding an agency's approach to AI has become an important part of evaluating its capabilities.

The 2026 AgencyAnalytics Marketing Agency Benchmarks Report, based on responses from 494 agency professionals, found that 79% reported saving at least five hours per week using AI.

These efficiency gains can help agencies spend less time on repetitive tasks and more time on strategic work. Plus, they can reduce costs for your business, particularly for marketing material production, testing, and analysis. 

However, simply using AI tools doesn't make an agency more effective.

You should understand how the agency incorporates AI into its workflows, where human expertise remains essential, and how it protects your business information.

What a strong answer looks like

An agency's AI expertise should extend beyond knowing how to use popular tools. It should understand those tools' limitations and know when human review, original research, and professional judgment are necessary.

Red flag to watch out for

Be cautious if an agency treats AI as a complete replacement for marketing expertise or claims its tools guarantee better campaign results. Other concerns include excessive reliance on unreviewed AI-generated content, no clear data protection policies, and an inability to explain how AI improves actual business outcomes. 

These things should become clear in how they present their use of AI. 

6. Who Will Manage My Account, and How Will We Communicate?

Even the most capable marketing agency can become a frustrating partner if communication is inconsistent or responsibilities aren't clearly defined.

That's why it's important to understand who will manage your account, who will execute the work, and how you'll communicate throughout the partnership.

The people presenting the agency's proposal may not be the same people responsible for your campaigns. Before signing a contract, ask to meet the account manager and key specialists who will handle your business.

You should also establish how frequently the agency will provide updates, hold meetings, and respond to questions or urgent requests.

Communication becomes especially important when campaigns underperform, business priorities change, or unexpected challenges arise.

What a strong answer looks like

A professional agency should clearly explain its account management structure and communication processes. That includes a primary contact, meeting frequency, response expectations, and communication channels. 

Ideally, the agency should also explain how it handles feedback, changes in campaign priorities, and disagreements about marketing decisions.

Red flag to watch out for

Watch out for agencies that are vague about who will manage your account or refuse to introduce the delivery team before signing the contract. Slow responses during the sales process may also indicate future communication problems. 

7. How Will You Measure and Report Marketing Performance?

Marketing results should be measurable, but what counts as success depends on your objectives.

For example, a brand awareness campaign might focus on reach, brand lift, or audience engagement. A lead generation campaign would typically prioritize qualified leads, conversion rates, and customer acquisition costs.

Before hiring an agency, ask how it selects key performance indicators (KPIs), tracks progress, and reports outcomes.

The agency should be able to connect marketing metrics with real business results. 

And the reports shouldn’t be all numbers, but insightful observations and expert opinions. A good performance report should answer three fundamental questions: What's working, what's underperforming, and what should happen next?

What a strong answer looks like

A reliable agency should propose a reporting framework based on your marketing objectives, with clearly defined KPIs and a consistent measurement process.

Depending on your campaigns, these might include:

  • Lead generation: Qualified leads, cost per lead, lead-to-customer conversion rate, and pipeline contribution.
  • Paid advertising: Cost per acquisition, ROAS, conversion rates, and advertising profitability.
  • SEO: Organic search visibility, relevant traffic, engagement, and conversions.
  • Content marketing: Content engagement, assisted conversions, and lead generation.
  • Customer acquisition: Acquisition costs, customer lifetime value, and revenue generated.

The agency should also explain which analytics platforms it uses, how it handles attribution, and whether you'll have direct access to dashboards and advertising accounts.

Red flag to watch out for

Be cautious if an agency focuses almost entirely on vanity metrics, such as impressions, followers, or traffic, without explaining their business value.

8. What Will the Partnership Cost, and What Are the Contract Terms?

Price is an important consideration when hiring a marketing agency. You want a cost-effective partnership.

Agency pricing usually falls into one of four categories: 

  • Fixed retainer 
  • Hourly rate
  • Project-based
  • Outcome-based

The right model depends on the services you need (and what the agency offers, since they also decide how they want to get paid). 

A flat pricing number doesn’t tell the whole story. The proposal should highlight costs by line item. Services, tools, and any extra things should be mentioned and factored into the cost. 

Before comparing proposals, make sure you understand exactly what's included in each price.

What a strong answer looks like

A reliable agency should provide a detailed proposal or statement of work explaining its pricing, responsibilities, and contractual obligations.

Review the following areas carefully:

  • Pricing structure: Whether you'll pay a monthly retainer, project fee, hourly rate, or performance-based fee.
  • Scope of work: The services, activities, and deliverables included in the agreed price.
  • Additional costs: Advertising spend, software subscriptions, production expenses, and charges for extra work.
  • Payment terms: Billing schedules, payment deadlines, and any required deposits.
  • Contract duration: Minimum commitments, renewal arrangements, and opportunities to review performance.
  • Cancellation terms: Notice periods, termination fees, and the process for ending the relationship.
  • Asset ownership: Who owns the advertising accounts, campaign data, creative assets, and content produced during the partnership.

Also ask what happens when the partnership ends, including whether the agency will provide campaign documentation, transfer relevant assets, and support a smooth transition.

When comparing proposals, consider the overall value of the services.

Red flag to watch out for

Avoid agencies that provide vague pricing, refuse to explain additional charges, or pressure you into signing a contract before you've reviewed the terms.

Final Thoughts: Choose a Marketing Agency That Fits Your Goals

Hiring a marketing agency is an important business decision that should involve more than comparing prices, portfolios, and sales presentations.

The eight questions covered in this guide will help you assess an agency's expertise, past performance, strategic capabilities, use of AI, communication practices, reporting standards, and contractual terms.

Before making your decision, consider shortlisting three agencies and asking each the same core questions. This makes it easier to compare their strengths, identify potential concerns, and determine which provider best matches your requirements.

A free course to

Master the No-Code Fundamentals in Just 7 Days

By clicking Get Lesson 1 you're confirming that you agree with our Terms and Conditions.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Occasionally, we send you a really good curation of profitable niche ideas, marketing advice, no-code, growth tactics, strategy tear-dows & some of the most interesting internet-hustle stories.

By clicking Subscribe you're confirming that you agree with our Terms and Conditions.
Thank You.
Your submission has been received.
Now please head over to your email inbox and confirm your subscription to start receiving the newsletter.
Oops!
Something went wrong. Please try again.