Client Acquisition Statistics for Agencies in 2026: Lead Sources, Pitch Win Rates, Sales Cycles, Outreach Benchmarks, and Pipeline Health

In 2026, winning new clients remains the single most cited challenge across the agency industry. According to the most recently published benchmark surveys, 34% of marketing agency leaders say acquiring new clients is their top operational pain point, outranking time pressures, profit margins, and team management. For professional services firms more broadly, more than half report it is harder to land new business than it was the year prior. And for those who do break through, the journey is long: 78% of professional services firms say it now takes up to six months to close new deals.

The data reveals an industry still heavily reliant on a single acquisition channel. In two independent surveys of more than 600 and 250 agencies respectively, referrals from existing and past clients were identified as the dominant source of new business, cited by 66% to 74% of respondents. Only 6% of agencies named outbound sales as their top lead source. The largest share of agencies report converting 25% to 49% of qualified leads into clients, with the average pitch win rate for agency presentations sitting at 22%. New business directors at agencies last fewer than two years in 76% of cases, creating structural continuity risk in business development pipelines.

At the channel level, cold email reply rates average 5.1% in 2024, down from 7% the prior year. LinkedIn InMail delivers response rates of 10% to 25%. Personalized LinkedIn connection requests with a message achieve reply rates of 9.36%, compared to 5.44% for requests without any message. And 90% of decision-makers report they will not return cold calls or cold emails but will respond to someone introduced through their network or with an established professional brand.

This article compiles more than 60 client acquisition statistics for agencies drawn from primary surveys, platform research, industry benchmarking studies, sales performance data, and specialist new business reports published within the last two years. Data spans lead source distribution, pitch and conversion rates, sales cycle length, cold outreach benchmarks, referral dynamics, pipeline health indicators, new business director retention, niche specialization impact, and regional patterns.

Scope and Methodology

Includes only publicly available client acquisition statistics for agencies relevant for 2026.
Based on the latest figures published within the last two years.
Sources include primary research, first-party platform data, institutional studies, and industry reports.
Each statistic is listed separately with its original source and study context.
No estimates, forecasts, interpretations, or recommendations are included.

Key Client Acquisition Statistics for Agencies in 2026

34% of marketing agency leaders cite new client acquisition as their single biggest operational challenge, ahead of time pressures, profit margins, and team management, based on the AgencyAnalytics 2025 Marketing Agency Benchmarks Report, a survey of more than 220 agency leaders published at AgencyAnalytics.
66% of digital agencies and consultants say referrals from existing and past clients are the top source of new business, based on the SparkToro and Paddy Moogan State of Digital Agencies 2025 survey of 612 agency owners and consultants, published at SparkToro.
The average agency pitch win rate is 22%, meaning agencies win fewer than one in four of the formal pitches they participate in, based on a 2024 R3 Worldwide survey cited in a 2025 marketing agency statistics compilation by Amra and Elma.
34% of agencies convert 31% to 50% of the pitches they deliver, with roughly a one-in-three chance that any given pitch results in a signed client, based on the AgencyAnalytics 2025 Marketing Agency Benchmarks Report published at AgencyAnalytics.
More than half of professional services firms reported it is harder to land new business in 2025 than it was in 2024, driven by fewer opportunities and greater difficulty breaking through to decision-makers, based on the RSW/US 2025 Professional Services New Business Survey Report, a survey of senior-level executives conducted during April and May 2025 published at RSW/US.
78% of professional services firms say new deals are now taking up to six months to close, reflecting longer and more complex B2B buying cycles, based on the RSW/US 2025 Professional Services New Business Survey Report published at RSW/US.
83% of agencies closed new business within one to six months in 2024, an eight-point improvement from the prior year, based on the RSW/US 2024 Agency New Business Report, a survey of agency executives across the U.S. published at RSW/US.
74.1% of marketing agencies say referrals are the most effective client acquisition source, and 68.9% cite word of mouth, while only 31.9% say SEO and content marketing is their most effective acquisition source, based on a 2024 survey cited in a marketing agency statistics compilation by My Codeless Website.
69.6% of marketing agency respondents identified new business sales as the most challenging aspect of their sales pipeline, based on a survey cited in a 2025 marketing agency statistics compilation by My Codeless Website.
High Growth professional services firms grew at a median rate of 41% in the most recently published study year, four times faster than their peers, and enjoyed 25% profitability, compared to industry-wide median growth of 14%, based on the Hinge Research Institute 2024 High Growth Study of professional services firms, published at Hinge Marketing.
36% of agencies reported that their pipeline had improved compared to the prior year in 2025, up from 30% who said the same in 2024, based on the SparkToro and Paddy Moogan State of Digital Agencies 2025 survey of 612 agency owners and consultants, published at SparkToro.
62% of professional services firms are packaging their services into productized offerings, and 86% plan to increase this approach as a way to simplify decisions for prospects and scale profitably, based on the RSW/US 2025 Survey Report: Rolling Into 2026, a survey of senior-level executives conducted in August 2025 published at RSW/US.

Lead Source and Referral Statistics

Referrals from existing and past clients remain the top lead source for agencies across all survey years, with 66% of agencies naming them as their primary business development driver in 2025, based on the SparkToro and Paddy Moogan State of Digital Agencies 2025 survey published at SparkToro.
15% of agencies say referrals from partner companies are their top driver of new business, making partnerships the second-largest referral source after existing clients, based on the SparkToro and Paddy Moogan State of Digital Agencies 2025 survey published at SparkToro.
Speaking at events and conferences jumped from 6th to 4th place as a driver of new business referrals among digital agencies, overtaking outbound sales activity and social media platforms, based on the SparkToro and Paddy Moogan State of Digital Agencies 2025 survey published at SparkToro.
Only 6% of agencies named outbound sales activity as their number one source of new business, making it one of the least-used primary acquisition channels, based on the SparkToro and Paddy Moogan State of Digital Agencies 2024 survey of 612 agency owners published at SparkToro.
60% of agencies have tried some form of outbound sales or lead generation, but over half said their efforts were only moderately effective and 34% said outbound efforts were not effective at all, based on the SparkToro and Paddy Moogan State of Digital Agencies 2024 survey published at SparkToro.
Direct outreach surged to 52% as a top discovery channel for agencies in 2025, up significantly from prior years, with relationships still ranked first but outreach gaining rapidly, based on the RSW/US 2025 New Year Outlook Report, a survey of senior-level marketing and agency executives conducted in November and December 2024 with a sample of over 5,000 firms, published at RSW/US.
16% of agencies attract new clients through their own SEO and content marketing efforts, a channel that disproportionately benefits larger agencies, with 42% of those using content and SEO having over 50 clients, based on the AgencyAnalytics 2023 Agency Benchmarks Survey published at AgencyAnalytics.
24% of agencies access new clients through referrals from existing clients, while cold calls, outreach, and social media ranked at the bottom of client acquisition strategies in frequency and effectiveness, based on the AgencyAnalytics 2023 Agency Benchmarks Survey published at AgencyAnalytics.
More than half of smaller agencies (2 to 25 employees) that participated in technology vendor partner programs in a survey of 87 agencies, suggesting vendor partnerships represent an underutilized but adopted new business channel, based on the Databox and Harness & Hone Agency Client Acquisition Survey of 87 marketing agencies conducted in October and November 2023, published at Databox.

Pitch, Conversion, and Sales Cycle Statistics

39% of agencies report a qualified-lead-to-client conversion rate of 25% to 49%, which survey authors describe as approximately average but lower than historical norms, based on the SparkToro and Paddy Moogan State of Digital Agencies 2025 survey of 612 agency owners and consultants, published at SparkToro.
48% of agencies reported difficulties winning new clients in 2024, a 10-point decline from the prior year and the first improvement since 2021, based on the RSW/US 2024 Agency New Business Report published at RSW/US.
38% of agencies reported an increase in new business opportunities in 2024, a significant improvement from 29% who said the same in 2023, based on the RSW/US 2024 Agency New Business Report published at RSW/US.
76% of agencies reported that their new business directors last fewer than two years, creating structural pipeline disruption as experience and relationships are lost, based on the RSW/US 2024 Agency New Business Report published at RSW/US.
The overall win rate for sales organizations in 2025 fell into the 21% to 25% bracket, down from the 31% to 40% bracket in 2024, reflecting broader market tightening, based on the Outreach Sales 2025 Data Report published at Outreach.
Opportunities that include at least one live meeting have 32-day shorter deal cycles and significantly higher win rates compared to those that do not include a meeting, based on Outreach platform data from the Sales 2025 Data Report published at Outreach.
It takes an average of 5 to 7 contact touches to reach a prospect for the first time, and nearly every contact responds within 7 touches or fewer, based on the Outreach Sales 2025 Data Report published at Outreach.
67% of marketing agencies do not use discounts to win new clients, and among those that do, 24% offer volume-based incentives for larger retainers and 16% provide benefits for prepaid long-term contracts, based on the AgencyAnalytics 2025 Marketing Agency Benchmarks Report published at AgencyAnalytics.

Cold Outreach Benchmarks

Cold email reply rates averaged 5.1% in 2024, down from approximately 7% the prior year, with approximately 95% of cold emails failing to generate any response, based on 2025 cold email benchmark analysis by Martal Group.
The average cold email open rate in 2024 was 27.7%, while only 23.9% of sales emails are opened on average, based on analysis cited in a 2025 cold email statistics overview by Martal Group.
Follow-up emails increase reply rates by 50% or more, with two follow-up emails identified as the recommended minimum for B2B outreach effectiveness, based on cold email benchmark analysis published at Martal Group.
LinkedIn outreach reply rates average 10.3%, twice the average cold email reply rate of 5.1%, based on analysis of over 70,130 real campaigns from the Expandi LinkedIn automation platform published at Expandi.
LinkedIn connection requests that include a personalized message achieve a reply rate of 9.36%, compared to 5.44% for connection requests sent without any message, based on analysis of over 20 million LinkedIn outreach attempts from January 1 to December 31, 2024, published by Belkins.
90% of decision-makers will not return cold calls or cold emails, but 87% will respond to someone introduced through their network or who has an established professional brand, based on LinkedIn State of Sales data cited in a 2026 LinkedIn statistics overview by Martal Group.
LinkedIn InMail response rates range from 18% to 25%, compared to 3% or less for traditional cold email, based on LinkedIn platform data cited in a 2026 LinkedIn statistics overview by Sales So.
LinkedIn outreach tied to a recent activity such as a webinar attendance or role change boosts response rates by 32%, based on LinkedIn Sales Navigator data cited in a 2026 LinkedIn outreach guide by Martal Group.
Sequenced follow-up messages spaced two to five business days apart improve conversions by 49% over single-message outreach attempts, based on LinkedIn Sales Navigator data cited in a 2026 LinkedIn outreach guide by Martal Group.
66.9% of outbound campaigns now combine LinkedIn and email simultaneously rather than relying on a single channel, based on data cited in a 2026 LinkedIn outreach guide by Martal Group.

Pipeline Health and New Business Director Statistics

14% of agencies described their sales pipeline as very healthy in 2025, a slight increase from 13% in 2024, while 32% described their pipeline as not good, down from 36% in 2024, based on the SparkToro and Paddy Moogan State of Digital Agencies 2025 survey of 612 agency owners and consultants, published at SparkToro.
Agencies with 51 or more employees reported their pipelines as very healthy at a substantially higher rate than smaller agencies, indicating that pipeline quality improves significantly with firm size, based on the SparkToro and Paddy Moogan State of Digital Agencies 2025 survey published at SparkToro.
79% of agencies do not have a person dedicated specifically to their own marketing, with the job typically falling to the founders, based on the SparkToro and Paddy Moogan State of Digital Agencies 2025 survey published at SparkToro.
77% of agencies believe they are ahead of the curve on marketing trends for their clients, but only 62% of marketers who work with them agree, indicating a significant perception gap, based on the RSW/US 2025 New Year Outlook Report published at RSW/US.
73% of agencies say AI-powered personalization will be the defining new business trend, based on the RSW/US 2025 New Year Outlook Report of over 5,000 marketing and agency executives published at RSW/US.
Most agencies gain between 1 and 20 new clients per year, based on a survey of 87 marketing agencies conducted in October and November 2023, published by Databox and Harness & Hone.
88% of surveyed agency leaders believe specializing in a specific industry vertical can positively impact client acquisition rate, but very few have actually niched down or plan to do so, based on a survey of 87 marketing agencies published by Databox and Harness & Hone.

Revenue and Business Impact Statistics

High Growth professional services firms that grow 3 times faster than average are also 2 times more profitable than their slower-growing counterparts, based on the Hinge Research Institute 2024 High Growth Study, the ninth edition of the annual study, published at Hinge Marketing.
High Growth technology and software firms invest approximately 10% of revenues in marketing, double the industry average of 5%, which delivers dramatically faster growth rates, based on the Hinge Research Institute 2025 High Growth Study, Technology and Software Edition, published at Hinge Marketing.
Customer acquisition costs have risen 222% over the past eight years across industries, with the acceleration most pronounced in digital channels due to competition, privacy regulation changes, and fragmenting consumer attention, based on SimplicityDX research cited in a 2025 CAC benchmarks analysis by Genesys Growth.
The average CAC payback period for private SaaS companies is 23 months, meaning agencies and tech firms operate at an acquisition loss for nearly two years before new clients become profitable, based on SaaS Capital 2025 Survey data cited in a 2025 CAC trends analysis by Phoenix Strategy Group.
60% of surveyed digital agencies expected their revenue to increase over the following year in a mid-2024 survey, reflecting cautious optimism about client demand for marketing services, based on the SparkToro and Paddy Moogan State of Digital Agencies 2024 survey of 612 agency owners cited in a 2025 independent agency analysis by Tapflare.
Businesses that text their customers as part of new business nurturing are 683% more likely to report digital marketing success, based on SimpleTexting’s fifth annual SMS marketing report of 1,400 respondents published at SimpleTexting.
62% of clients who were not upsold within the first three months of engagement churned within two years, making early service expansion a direct function of long-term client acquisition economics, based on the Vendasta 2023 Agency Insights Report cited in a 2025 agency revenue analysis by Vendasta.

Regional or Geographic Statistics

Agencies with 51 or more employees consistently report healthier pipelines and higher pitch-to-client conversion rates than agencies of fewer than 10 employees, with the trend holding across all regions surveyed, based on the SparkToro and Paddy Moogan State of Digital Agencies 2025 survey of 612 agencies published at SparkToro.
95% of professional services firms responding to the RSW/US 2025 survey had fewer than 50 employees, reflecting the prevalence of small to mid-sized agencies in the North American new business landscape, based on the RSW/US 2025 Professional Services New Business Survey Report conducted with firms across the U.S. and Canada published at RSW/US.
The legal and professional services sector shows the highest LinkedIn outreach response rate of 10.42% among all industries analyzed, while software and SaaS sectors show lower-than-average engagement to cold LinkedIn prospecting, based on Expandi analysis of over 70,130 outreach campaigns published at Expandi.
Global marketing services spending is projected to grow from USD 452.96 billion in 2025 to USD 571.53 billion by 2030 at a CAGR of approximately 4.8%, increasing the overall addressable market for agency client acquisition, based on Mordor Intelligence data cited in a 2025 independent agency growth analysis by Tapflare.
Tuesday achieves the highest LinkedIn reply rates of any day of the week at 6.90%, followed closely by Monday at 6.85%, while weekend outreach drops significantly to 6.40% on Saturdays, based on Expandi analysis of over 70,130 outreach campaigns published at Expandi.

References

‍

Subscribe to our newsletter

Occasionally, we send you a really good curation of profitable niche ideas, marketing advice, no-code, growth tactics, strategy tear-dows & some of the most interesting internet-hustle stories.

Thank You.
Your submission has been received.
Now please head over to your email inbox and confirm your subscription to start receiving the newsletter.

Oops!
Something went wrong. Please try again.